Apple Butter Recipe

October 5, 2012Holly Sosa

“It’s like apple pie in a jar!” J said to me after he tasted my apple butter this morning.  People, by now you know that I am all about the holidays & seasons.  I am not afraid to celebrate & a change of weather or holiday is a perfect excuse.  Fall is creeping up on us here in the desert now that the October heatwave is fading.  Mornings are becoming more crisp & the evening sun sets more quickly these days.

One of my favorite things to do in the fall is to make my annual trip to Gilcrease Orchard back in Vegasland.  I started this last year with Collin & my sister & we loved it.  It was a little taste of Michigan right there in the desert.  They have apple trees, pear trees & tons of other veggies & fruits to pick.  Naturally, they have pumpkins there too.  They also sell apple cider & cider donuts!

This year, Collin was hanging with his Daddy, so J & I went with just Aiden.  Little dude was a pro at apple picking.  He picked us eleven pounds of apples.  Eleven pounds.  Good thing I was raised with the know how to cook & bake because coming up with recipes for eleven pounds of apples was a cinch!

Sure, we had a few afternoons of sliced apples & peanut butter for a snack & of course I made an apple pie, but for the most part I knew exactly what to do with every single one of those apples: apple butter.

Before embarking on apple butter, know this: your entire house.  Every crevice of your home.  Will smell like fall.  Cinnamon-y, nutmeg-y, apple-y fall.  And you’ll love it.

I received a few requests for my recipe after people saw my IG feed (hollysosa) fill with photos of diced up apples & a full crock pot, so I decided to share it here.

Ingredients you’ll need: a dozen apples (I used granny smith), white sugar, ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg, ground cloves & salt (not pictured).
Directions: Peel, dice & core all your apples & toss those bad boys in your crock pot.  In a medium bowl, mix four cups of sugar, 1/4 teaspoon of nutmeg, 1/4 teaspoon of ground cloves, a whole teaspoon of cinnamon & 1/4 teaspoon of salt.  Once the sugar mix is well distributed, pour it over top of your apples & mix well.  Cook everything on high for an hour to get things going.  After an hour, go stir everything up (you’ll see it getting watery) & then turn the heat down to low & cook an additional 9-10 hours stirring every couple of hours.  The additional time really depends on your apples.  These ones were really dense & actually took me close to 12 hours until they were done.  Lots of people start this at night or first thing in the morning since it needs a lot of time to cook.  When it’s done, the apples will be cooked down almost completely.  There may be a few chunky pieces here or there, but for the most part, it will look sort of grainy & super dark brown (almost black, even).  This recipe makes a little over two medium sized mason jars full.
For those who have never had apple butter or don’t know it’s uses (I’m pretty sure this is more of a mid-west thing), it’s used on tons of stuff!  My grandpa used to warm some up & put it on vanilla ice cream. My Dad always used it on his toast in the fall.  I love it mixed in with my oatmeal.  Some people just eat it straight out of the can in a bowl (it’s essentially just a sweeter, condensed version of applesauce).  I also know people who cook with it on their pork chops & I’ve made an easter ham using it as a glaze. Another idea I’ve seen, but haven’t tried is to heat up some four tortillas in oil & put the apple butter inside as a dessert.
Apple butter is fall in a jar.  It is a fun, cheap & easy fall treat for the kids, too.


  • Sarah Halstead

    October 25, 2012 at 3:50 AM

    Yummy! Can’t wait!

  • ourhollydays

    October 25, 2012 at 6:04 PM

    The best part is the way the house smells while it’s cooing! Haha!

  • Fall? Check. | Our Holly Days

    December 31, 2014 at 3:48 PM

    […] our apple picking already.  I have been baking every apple recipe under the sun, including my apple butter.  I hosted a fall swap.  We are gearing up for Collin’s birthday.  I decorated […]

  • Elfing DIY with Pear Tree Greetings | Our Holly Days

    January 1, 2015 at 9:04 PM

    […] a tradition that J & I decided to start with the kids this year.  I had some extra apple butter from the batch I made, so we decided to use it for the neighbors’ elf treat.  And Pear […]

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post Next Post